Editor
- PTA is remitted to dam “illegal content material”, says minister.
- Authority finishing up its perform below Section 37 of Peca 2016.
- WMS makes use of Deep Packet Inspection know-how to dam VPN site visitors.
LAHORE: The National Assembly has been knowledgeable that the Pakistan Telecommunication Authority (PTA) is utilizing the controversial Web Monitoring System (WMS) to dam on-line purposes and web sites in Pakistan.
The minister in cost for the cupboard division, a division that has administrative management over the PTA, was questioned in regards to the PTA’s procedures for blocking internet purposes within the nation.
In a written response despatched on August 26, the minister defined that the PTA is remitted to dam “illegal content material” below Section 37 of the Prevention of Electronic Crimes Act (PECA) 2016. While the PTA additionally submits complaints and requests for removing and blocking of purposes on to internet hosting entities reminiscent of Apple and Google, it has deployed the WMS for “web content material administration.”
The minister admitted that the PTA has been utilizing the WMS to dam purposes and web sites inside Pakistan. “The PTA has until date blocked a complete of 469 cellular purposes (435 Android and 34 Apple) associated to varied classes together with purposes towards the glory of Islam, indecent/immoral content material, and fraudulent actions,” the response said.
Social media website X (previously often called Twitter) has been formally blocked in Pakistan since February 17, and the web site of the opposition political celebration Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf has remained inaccessible since earlier than the elections.
It is price noting that on August 15, Minister of State for Information Technology Shaza Khawaja Fatima claimed that the WMS was essential to “take care of cyber safety assaults within the nation.” However, the minister answerable for the cupboard division’s response to the National Assembly makes no point out of cyber safety considerations when blocking content material.
The controversial Web Monitoring System (recognized additionally because the Web Management System) was acquired by Pakistan in 2018 from the Canada-based firm Sandvine for $18.5 million, in keeping with a report by Coda.
In December 2023, the WMS was additional upgraded and examined on touchdown stations for web submarine cables SMW 3, 4, and 5, a PTA spokesperson had advised Geo TV earlier this yr. The PTA claims that this “improve” led to nationwide web outages and slowdowns previous to the elections.
The WMS employs Deep Packet Inspection know-how to determine and block VPN site visitors. It additionally permits authorities surveillance of all web site visitors coming to and from Pakistan, wrote journalist and digital rights activist Ramsha Jahangir in Dawn.
However, the minister answerable for the cupboard division admitted to the National Assembly that regardless of its try to dam content material on the gateway stage the content material may nonetheless be accessed in Pakistan by VPNs, including that VPN customers who “bypass the gateway by their personal site visitors are additionally bypassing the state coverage concerning banned content material.”
It needs to be famous that authorities officers, together with ministers and the prime minister himself, have been utilizing X (previously Twitter) regardless of its official ban in Pakistan. It is unclear whether or not they’re accessing the platform by VPNs.
“It may be very troublesome for PTA to successfully adjust to PECA’s obligations with out controlling VPN misuse,” the minister wrote in his written reply. The minister additionally revealed that the PTA had been working with the Ministry of Information Technology, the Pakistan Software Export Board, and P@SHA to “whitelist” IPs and VPNs within the nation, having registered 20,437 VPNs up to now.
Additionally, the PTA has launched an e-portal for presidency organisations to lodge complaints and request content material removing or blocking. To date, 47 stakeholders, together with federal and provincial ministries and legislation enforcement businesses, are utilizing the e-portal.
Ramsha Jahangir advised The News that the federal government and PTA’s disclosures to lawmakers clearly point out that the Web Monitoring System is getting used for whitelisting VPNs and blocking on-line content material. “They [PTA] have additionally acknowledged inserting blocks on the gateway stage. The cybersecurity or cable fault cowl doesn’t maintain anymore,” she mentioned.
Jahangir added that, given the precedent of web filtering in Pakistan by the WMS, it’s now much more essential for authorities to be clear about their plans. “Who bought the WMS? Where did the funds come from?” she requested.
